Fishers Theft Crime Lawyer

Theft Crime Attorney in Fishers, IN

If you or a loved one has been arrested for a theft crime in Indiana, it is only natural to feel scared and uncertain. The criminal justice system in Hamilton County can be confusing and overwhelming. It can leave you with more questions than answers. At Blankenship Law, LLC, our skilled Fishers theft crime lawyer is here to stand by your side and protect your rights.

Fishers and the surrounding Hamilton County are no strangers to theft crimes. In 2022, theft was the most common crime in the area, with 828 incidents reported for the year. 

At Blankenship Law, LLC, we understand how one single mistake at a home in Tremont or a misunderstanding at the Fishers District shopping mall on Yard Street can lead to serious charges. We’re here to help you defend yourself against theft charges.

Get a Former Prosecutor on Your Side When You Work with Blankenship Law, LLC

After passing the bar exam in 2002, founding attorney Eric Blankenship worked as a prosecutor for 17 years. After working on well over 100 court and jury trials, he realized his time and talents were better suited to help those facing criminal charges. As an experienced Fishers criminal defense lawyer, he uses his prosecutorial experience to anticipate the state’s tactics and build a robust defense for his clients.

At Blankenship Law, LLC, we are passionate about helping those who find themselves at the wrong place at the wrong time. One bad decision should not put you behind bars for the rest of your life or harm the entire course of your future. Our attorneys are here for you. To listen to your side of the story and argue on behalf of the person, not the law. 

In a theft crime case, you need someone who actually sits down and takes the time to understand your side of the charges being leveled against you. We know this is a scary time–there’s a lot at risk–but we are here to help and to act as your trusted guide. At Blankenship Law, LLC, we are here to guide you through to the very end.

Common Theft Charges in Fishers, Indiana

In Fishers, Indiana, theft is any criminal act in which an individual seizes property that does not belong to them, with the direct intention of depriving the owner of the property’s value or use. There are several criminal charges that fall under the category of theft and include:

• Shoplifting or retail theft
• Conversion
• Grand theft
• Embezzlement
• Petty theft
• Auto theft, which, according to the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Department, has seen 31% decrease from 2024 to 2025
• Credit card theft
• Receiving stolen property or assets
• Felony theft
• Misdemeanor theft
• Writing a fraudulent check
• Identity theft, for which the number of first-time identity theft victims rose from 31% to 37% in 2024

If you or someone you love has been accused of any of these forms of theft, you must reach out to the team at Blankenship Law, LLC right away so we can protect your rights. 

Defense Strategies Used to Protect Your Rights

An experienced attorney from Blankenship Law, LLC, can review your case and determine which defense strategy works optimally to protect your rights. The most common defense strategies for theft crimes in Fishers include:

• Showing a lack of intent on the part of the defendant
• Demonstrating that the defendant suffered a mistaken identity
• Proving that the defendant had the owner’s consent regarding the property in question
• That the defendant acted only under duress or coercion
• Proving that there is a lack of evidence to support the prosecution’s case

While one strategy might work in one case, it might be less effective in another. Instead of guessing on what tactic you should use, work with a criminal defense attorney. They can create a customized plan to increase your chances of success.

FAQs

What Factors Can Make Theft a Felony in IN?

In Indiana, theft can be considered a Level 6 felony charge should the involved stolen property be worth at least $750 but less than $50,000. Additionally, felony theft must occur in a manner that shows the defendant acted with intent or in a knowing manner, or that the defendant lacked any permission or legal right to take or use the property. 

What Forms of Evidence Could Help Me Defend My Case?

To defend your case, multiple forms of evidence can prove useful. This can include any witness testimony that helps support your defense, any financial or communication records that apply, or any data or testimony that can support an alibi, or show that you were at a different place at the time of the alleged theft. 

What Are the Penalties for Theft in Fishers?

In Fishers, there are many penalties one can face if convicted of a theft crime. You may be required to serve probation, pay fines, make restitution payments to the alleged victims, and participate in community service. You may also suffer collateral consequences, such as a lack of future job opportunities and housing, and be denied any immigration visa or permanent residency status.  

Can a Conviction for Theft Be Expunged in Indiana?

Yes, a conviction for theft may be expunged in Indiana, but only under very specific circumstances. You must meet the requirement criteria. You need to complete all of your original sentencing terms and the waiting period specified in your case. It is wise to only seek an expungement with the help of an experienced criminal defense lawyer. 

Hire a Theft Crime Lawyer Today

When you have been charged with a theft crime, you need a seasoned attorney who can competently review your situation and prepare you for the legal process ahead. At Blankenship Law, LLC, our team is here for you and can walk beside you every step of the way.

When the time comes to hire a theft crime lawyer in Fishers, Indiana, look no further than the experienced team at Blankenship Law, LLC. You need a strong and solid defense, and that’s what you get when you contact us today for a consultation. 

Fishers, IN Theft Crime Resources

• What Does a Criminal Defense Lawyer Do in Indiana?
• Understanding Theft Crimes in Indiana: How Blankenship Law Can Help
• When Can You Legally Use Force in Indiana—And Why You Still Need a Defense Lawyer
• A Fresh Start: Understanding Expungements in Indiana
• Being Accused of a Violent Crime Could Cost You Everything Without the Right Defense