Theft Crimes Dedicated Legal Defense from Start to Finish

Theft Crime Defense Attorney in Carmel, IN

Don’t Face Your Theft Charges Alone. Put a Proven Defense Lawyer on Your Side!

Your life can change in an instant following a theft crime charge. Prosecutors will pursue the maximum penalties and build their case against you as soon as they’re aware of your charge. It doesn’t help that the other side of the courtroom can spew brutal attacks which could intimidate even the most fearless people.

If you’re wondering how I know this, it’s because I was a former prosecutor for Marion County, the largest county in Indiana.

Trust me, I’ve seen it all. Now that I’m on the other side of the law, I understand how important it is to have a dedicated, experienced attorney who treats their clients like a friend — a valued human being — not just a case number. At Blankenship Law, LLC, I provide hard-hitting defense in the courtroom and compassionate counsel outside of court. Thus, when you hire me to defend your theft charges, I will fight tirelessly for your best interests as if it were my own freedom on the line.

Don’t hesitate to reach out to me at (317) 680-5528 if you have questions, concerns or want to get started on fighting your theft charges. Free, same-day consultations available!

Understanding Indiana’s Theft Laws

Indiana defines theft as a person who knowingly or intentionally exerts unauthorized control over property of another person, with intent to deprive the other person of any part of its value or use.

This offense is a Class A misdemeanor punishable by up to 1 year in prison and/or up to $5,000 fines. However, you can face harsher consequences under the following circumstances:

  • Level 6 felony: The value of the property is $750 to less than $50,000 or the stolen property is a firearm, motor vehicle or component part of a motor vehicle. If you have a prior unrelated conviction for theft or criminal conversion, you may suffer a Level 6 felony as well.
  • Level 5 felony: The value of the stolen property is at least $50,000 or the stolen property is a valuable metal as it relates to transportation or public safety, or the property is taken from a hospital, telecommunications provider, public utility or key facility and the absence of such property can create a risk of bodily injury. If you have a prior unrelated conviction for theft of a motor vehicle or component part, you could suffer a Level 5 felony charge.


Although there’s no statute on shoplifting in Indiana, burglary is defined as a person who breaks and enters the building or structure of another person, with intent to commit a felony or theft in it. This offense is a Level 5 felony but can be increased to a Level 4 felony if the building or structure is a dwelling.

You may get a level 3 felony charge if the burglary results in bodily injury to someone other than yourself, and a Level 2 felony if the offense is committed while armed with a deadly weapon or results in serious bodily injury to someone other than yourself.

The worst-case scenario is a Level 1 felony charge, which involves the offense being committed in a dwelling and results in serious bodily injury to someone other than yourself.

Defending Theft Crimes Accusations in Carmel, IN

It’s fair to say that Indiana does not take theft charges lightly. As such, you need a serious theft crime defense lawyer who knows what it takes to win. Depending on the circumstances of your unique case, I can employ defense strategies such as:

  • You owned the property
  • You returned the property
  • You were intoxicated
  • You were entrapped
  • You didn’t do it
  • You were misidentified as the suspect
  • The “victim” lied

These are some of the various avenues we can explore when you consult with me. After thoroughly reviewing your case, I can guide you through your legal options and work to put your theft charges behind you. Call (317) 680-5528 for a free case review!

Why You Want Blankenship Law 
On Your Side

 High-Quality, Experienced Counsel & Representation
  • Personalized Representation

    Attorney Eric Blankenship prides himself on being accessible and building a relationship with his clients.

  • Great Reputation

    Due to his previous prosecutor experience, Attorney Blankenship has created great relationships with every prosecutor in the area.

  • Trial Experience

    Experience matters when your future is on the line. Attorney Eric Blankenship has tried overĀ a hundred jury trials.

  • Former Prosecutor

    Attorney Eric Blankenship worked as a former Prosecutor in Marion County, which is the largest county of Indiana.

Client Reviews

Why People Choose to Work With Blankenship Law
  • “Blankenship was the most professional, hardest working lawyer I've ever met. He answered the phone every single time I called.”

    - Jason H.
  • “He answered all of my questions honestly and if he didn't know, he said so, and guided me in the right direction!”

    - Former Client
  • “Eric is a great lawyer and provides feedback that is easy to understand.”

    - Laina M
  • “If I ever found myself in a situation where I needed legal representation, the very first person I would call would be Eric Blankenship. As a former Prosecutor, Eric knows inner-workings of the legal and judicial systems.”

    - Jen C.
  • “My experience with Blankenship Law has been nothing short of fantastic. You can’t go wrong having him as your attorney!”

    - Courtney B.

Contact Us Today

 Let's Solve Your Legal Challenge

  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.